My aunt was living with me for a few years when tragedy struck my house. My husband passed away and I needed more help with my aunt. I tried having help at my house but it got to be more than anticipated. I decided to place her at Atria. The best decision I ever made. It’s not just an assisted living facility, it’s a home and so much more. They made my aunt feel welcome and the apartment was beautiful. She is surrounded by the most beautiful gardens and has so many different places to go You will never meet a better staff anywhere. They are all truly gifted as they take your loved one under their wings and provide so much love and caring. You can sleep at night knowing this amazing staff is on duty and their only concern is for your family member. I consider myself and my aunt truly blessed. Thank you to all of you!!... Read more
Tucked away on a parcel of land near the picturesque Great South Bay, Atria Bay Shore offers independent living, supportive living, and memory care in a grand community building. With an architecture design reminiscent of the classic Cape Cod style, this expansive building creates a bright and airy atmosphere for older adults in Bay Shore, New York. Situated near the New York City metropolitan area, Atria Bay Shore crafts a peaceful environment for seniors without sacrificing access to big-city amenities.
Nature-loving seniors can watch elegant watercrafts navigate the nearby waterways, or stroll along the peaceful waterfront. Restaurants and retail shops offer engaging spaces within a short drive of this community, while the nearby Bay Shore-Brightwaters Library provides free educational resources for seniors. Let your interests and passions guide your time at Atria Bay Shore.
Feel comfortable in this cheerful senior living community knowing that the staff remain available around the clock. Seniors can maximize their free time by utilizing community resources, including the community laundry, concierge, and shuttle services. Spend time relaxing on the well-maintained courtyard, stay physically active with a visit to the on-site fitness center, or snuggle up with a good book in the intimate library. Socialize through...
Read More
Learn more about the Best of Senior Living awards and this year’s winners. See all 2024 award winners.
Total monthly costs depend on room type, select services, and the level of care needed.
*Prices quoted are monthly rental charges and are provided by the communities themselves. Actual prices may differ due to one-time fees, timing and care services required. Speak with your Senior Living Advisor to learn more.
9.8
Review Score
Review Score
50 reviews9.8
Out of 10
5 star
66%
4 star
22%
3 star
10%
2 star
2%
1 star
0%
A Place for Mom has scored Atria Bay Shore with 9.8 out of 10 using our proprietary review score based on 18 reviews in the last 2 years. Over all time, Atria Bay Shore has 50 reviews with an average "overall experience" of 4.5 out of 5.
4.6
4.5
4.9
4.5
4.6
4.8
4.5
I visited with my mom to see her friend. The staff seem so nice, genuinely caring. The old feel of the building is very charming and cozy. There seems to be a lot to do from the calendar of events I saw. The residents look very happy and engaged with each other nicely. I really enjoyed my visit and talking with those that love there
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
My dad visited the community and was so pleased with what they offer. The community is clean, everyone was so friendly. He was able to talk with a few of the seniors that live there and they are genuinely happy. The building is beautiful and I can only hope he decides to move there.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
We found Atria to be a very comfortable experience for mom and for the family. The facility itself has a warm and relaxed atmosphere. The old mansion is beautiful and provides a very homelike feeling. Staff are friendly. Administrators were accessible to explain services and answer any questions. Landscaping and the grounds are charming. Ample program amenities like music, arts, exercise, and movies occur daily as scheduled. We were welcomed any time day or night.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
My aunt was living with me for a few years when tragedy struck my house. My husband passed away and I needed more help with my aunt. I tried having help at my house but it got to be more than anticipated. I decided to place her at Atria. The best decision I ever made. It’s not just an assisted living facility, it’s a home and so much more. They made my aunt feel welcome and the apartment was beautiful. She is surrounded by the most beautiful gardens and has so many different places to go You will never meet a better staff anywhere. They are all truly gifted as they take your loved one under their wings and provide so much love and caring. You can sleep at night knowing this amazing staff is on duty and their only concern is for your family member. I consider myself and my aunt truly blessed. Thank you to all of you!!
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
My brother has been in the Bay Shore Atria approximately 1 year. HE IS THRIVING AND SSSSSOOOOO HAPPY THERE, SO, OF COURSE WE ARE ECSTATIC! The staff are always available when and if needed. The amenities are so plentiful, each extraordinarily performed. The facility is beautiful and pristine in its cleanliness. I could not be happier for my brother. I
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
I would highly suggest if you place your loved one in this facility that you visit often and at different times. Some of the staff really lack compassion, they should be observed especially in the evenings where the residents are basically in their rooms or sitting in the living area “watching” tv. All interaction ceases in the later afternoon except for necessary tasks. There is very little assistance for anyone who has difficulty feeling theirselves. Meals are removed if not eaten within whatever time frame is allowed. Understaffing and supervision is most definitely a concern. Other reviews leave questions as so different from the observance of many family members who have seen the above, again this reflects the memory care unit.
4
3
5
2
No data collected
2
3
Response from Atria Bay Shore
June 7, 2024Ann, we appreciate your feedback. I’ve shared your review with the Executive Director, and she would appreciate the opportunity to speak with you directly about your concerns. You can reach her at the community, and I’m also available at CustomerService@AtriaSeniorLiving.com.
I would say it's the best ( although one of the hardest) decisions I have ever made. Mom is safe, has wonderful people to care for her- and is truly living her best life. My stress level is markedly lower! Thanks to everyone at Atria Bay Shore for all they do!!!
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
I would say that everyone is very warm, caring and responsive. They have helped my Mom adapt to her new living arrangements fairly quickly. She is now much more social than she has ever been. She takes part in many of the activities, which makes me happy, but yet surprises me quite a bit. We choose this community because of the feeling we got when we were there, the location, and the beautiful grounds. I felt very relaxed there and knew my mother would feel that way too. The community is located on a quiet street in a quiet neighborhood. That was very different from the other communities we looked at which were located on busy streets.
5
5
5
5
5
5
4
I was in the Atria to visit my aunt. The facility was very clean and the staff was friendly. The residents all seemed happy and there were a lot of activities for them to do. My aunt is very happy at the Atria.
5
5
5
5
5
5
No data collected
I visited atria and this particular facility is amazing. People they’re so friendly and courteous. Absolutely beautiful! As i drove up i seen beautiful flowers and landscape. It reminded me of a beautiful mansion.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
Our dad lived at the Atria for almost four years. It is a smaller facility that has beautiful grounds and rooms with high ceilings, tall windows letting in lots of light which all give the Atria more a feeling of home. More importantly, the staff is caring and attentive and engaging. Everyone from the front desk, to the aides, to the dining room staff, to Wellness, to the directors, to the lovely people that cleaned his room - all knew our dads likes, dislikes and quirks and were fast to respond to anything that seemed out of the ordinary. We were surprised not only how quickly dad adjusted to a life not as independent as he would have preferred, but how much he enjoyed his time here . That we can attribute to the people who work at the Atria.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
For two and a half years my mom got excellent care from the entire staff, from management down to the cleaning staff, could not imagine being in a better place.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
We are very happy with our life here at Atria bay shore. The staff are very helpful and very friendly. The food is good. A great place to live. We are enjoying it very much. The residents are friendly, welcoming and enjoy each others company.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
I have lived at the Atria Bay Shore for over a year now. It is a comfortable, secure, safe location. The staff is very nice and accommodating. My one bedroom apartment is spacious and accommodates all of my needs. The proximity to St. Patricks Church is perfect for me as I Catholic and attend mass at least twice a week. Main Street in downtown Bay Shore is a short walk from the Atria and the bandshell is a great location to enjoy outdoor musical entertainment in the summer months. The Atria staff works hard to keep residents engaged, entertained, active and save. The only thing I do not enjoy is the food. I think the chefs and kitchen staff try hard but the food is never hot when served. The cookies/desserts and salads are great but the main meal is never hot when served.
4
5
3
4
4
5
4
My mom is the happiest I have seen her in a long time! She is thriving at Atria! As she got older, her dementia increased as well as her ability to walk on her own. She never wanted to give up her independence but we saw that she was struggling to live on her own. Atria in Bay Shore answered all our prayers. I can’t say enough about the staff, the cleanliness, the food, and all of the many activities. The place is small enough so that everyone is treated with extra care. My husband and I love to go there each time we visit mom. The nursing staff, as well as the aides give my mom extra special attention. The director of memory care plans special trips to keep residents actively engaged. The lovely lady who does creative activities with the group is exceptional. The staff is so experienced at keeping residents physically active. I feel that I am blessed to have found Atria for my mom. It’s called peace of mind.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
Moving mom into the Atria in Bay Shore was truly the best decision I could have made! The staff here is caring, professional, and treat her like a family member. The meals are excellent, and the wait staff who serves them is top notch! Housekeeping staff keeps her room impeccably clean- She has become active in many activities, and is truly living her best life. Any second thoughts I might have had about this move have been erased!
5
5
5
5
5
5
4
Atria Bayshore is a small facility where the staff learns everyone’s names and offers many personal touches. Active efforts are taken to learn each Resident’s personal needs and interests, making them feel more comfortable and at home. The Staff at Atria Bayshore are very receptive to family members input and are terrific in communicating with care givers. Each Resident is met at their level and treated with respect. The atmosphere at Atria Bayshore is warm and caring, giving a real family feel. There are plenty of daily activities, field trips, movie nights and celebrations to keep our mom happy and active. The grounds are beautiful manicured and the food is truly delicious. Atria Bayshore gives our family peace of mind.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
My family visited this community and just love everything about it. It’s small, very clean. The staff are so friendly and helpful. The rooms are a nice size with a lot of light. So many fun things to do each day and the dining menu looks delicious. I can’t wait for my mom to move in next month.
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
Response from Atria Bay Shore
July 11, 2023We're grateful to have you and your family part of the Atria family. We appreciate your kind compliments and will be sure share with our team.
I had a lovely tour experience with Atria. I found the staff to be very professional and friendly. I was impressed with the facility overall.
I would tell others that it is a very nice community. They care about the residents that live here. The grounds are very beautiful. They say that they will be doing more activities after COVID restrictions lift.
5
5
No data collected
5
No data collected
5
5
See what the neighborhood has to offer and what’s nearby:
Atria Bay Shore offers Studio, 1 Bedroom and 2 Bedrooms. Learn more.
A Place for Mom has scored Atria Bay Shore 9.8 out of 10 using our proprietary review score.
We assign review scores to give a more reliable view into senior living communities and home care agencies. Our review scores prioritize reviews that are recent — the past 24 months — because we know families need current information when choosing senior care.
Those with many recent, positive reviews receive a high review score, while providers with few recent reviews — regardless of how positive — receive a lower review score. Communities with no recent reviews will not have a review score, even if older reviews are positive. The maximum A Place for Mom review score a community can receive is 10 points.
Call (631) 206-1200 to reach a resident at Atria Bay Shore.
To reach a resident at Atria Bay Shore call: (631) 206-1200
1bd, 2bd, Studio, Semi-Private
Gurwin Jewish provides a menu of options all on one campus. Gurwin pride shines through in all we do. Assisted Living by Gurwin: At Gurwin Jewish~ Fay J. Lindner Residences, you can have it all: the ultimate in luxurious assisted living in an environment that embraces the traditions of Jewish...
Studio, 1bd, 2bd, Semi-Private
The Bristal Assisted Living offers incomparable care, the finest luxury amenities, a packed activity calendar and so much more. Call today to schedule your visit.
Studio, 1bd, 2bd
Life is beautiful at Brandywine Senior Living. We have luxurious individual suites with a private bath and kitchen area. Meanwhile, on the other side of your door are services to meet your needs, and entertainment to enliven your spirit.With on-site–not–on–call licensed nurses only steps away, 24...
Studio, 1bd, 2bd, Semi-Private
Since 2006, The Bristal at Massapequa has served this community with a much needed, high-quality senior living solution. Here we help residents on the South Shore adapt and thrive to a new home and a better way of life. Massapequa, in particular, has much to offer, with numerous commercial...
Studio, 1bd, 2bd, Semi-Private
The Bristal at Lake Grove is a lovely assisted living community, situated just minutes from Long Island's historic Three Village Area. This is our third Suffolk County assisted living residence. Like all communities of The Bristal Assisted Living, the senior care that residents will experience...
Studio, 1bd, Semi-Private
As one of the most trusted senior living providers on Long Island, Atria East Northport has served families like yours for more than 25 years. With a continued commitment to quality, they have just completed a full-scale renovation to enhance the beauty and functionality of the community — and...
Studio, 1bd, Semi-Private, Detached Cottages / Bungalows
Birchwood Suites is a a fully enhanced assisted living community nestled on five acres of beautiful property in East Northport, NY. Our community offers a variety of luxury suites when life becomes too difficult or unsafe to live alone. Our Enhanced License, appointed by the New York State...
The features and amenities that are displayed on this page contain marketing information provided by the community. A Place for Mom has not confirmed the completeness of the provided information, and cannot guarantee its accuracy.
To conduct a complete investigation, seniors and their families should:
If you become aware of any information that should be updated or noted, please contact A Place for Mom.
A Place for Mom uses the term “assisted living” to indicate that the community provides some level of assistance with daily living activities. It does not indicate that the facility meets official state requirements for level of care.