A Place for Mom
Assisted Living
Memory Care
Independent Living
Senior Living
Sign in
30 Independent Living Facilities near Shelter Island, NY

Who are you searching for?

Parent
Spouse
Someone else
Myself
A Place for Mom
Who are you searching for?

10 Best Independent Living Communities in Shelter Island, NY

Last Updated: 11/9/24

If you’re looking for independent living in the Shelter Island area, our local senior living advisors can help you each step of the way. From affordable independent living for seniors to luxury options, we’ll work with you to understand the cost of independent living in Shelter Island. From there, we’ll show you the best independent living communities for your lifestyle, interests, and budget.

Discover unique independent living amenities, social activities, dining, and more independent living benefits. With 30 independent living facilities in Shelter Island, A Place for Mom makes it easier to find your new, maintenance-free home.


You may also consider nearby communities such as Southampton, Southampton or Montclair Colony.

Shelter Island Independent Living Facilities | 149 Reviews

Showing 30 communities
Last Updated: 11/9/24
Sort by
Filter by
Starting price (per month)
Average starting price of Independent Living in Shelter Island, NY is $7,209/month. Learn more
Review Score
Providers

Types of care available in Shelter Island, NY

Independent Living

Average starting price $7,209/month
Average starting price $10,028/month
Average starting price $9,949/month
Average starting price $10,265/month
Average starting price $3,454/month
Average starting price $969/month
Recent reviews of Independent Living in Shelter Island, NY
Crescent Point At Niantic
4.3

I'm pleased with the responsiveness of staff and think the pieces are in place for my aunt to have a good experience. I picked this community because of proximity to family and where my aunt used to live.

Riverhead Landing
4.5

This is a well maintained senior complex with amenities you might not expect to find. The pool is comfortable, the putting green is sufficient and the shuffle board and bocce ball are located near the pool. The grounds are manicured and management does an excellent job of keeping abreast of all that is occurring within the buildings. Space wise the two bedroom apartment is quite large with ample closet space, a nice patio or balcony space, and nice views. Each building is set up to provide a lovely view of trees and garden areas. I also viewed the one bedroom and it is also much larger than you would expect for the price charged. My only complaint is that some of the cabinets and the washer and dryer stackable units need to be updated. Otherwise my stay was terrific. The bonus factor for me was finding out how many seniors were in my midst not only at the complex but at the local stores and various locations. Great location, bus outside the main road at the front entrance and the complex exits to a big shopping center lot- with a grocery store, home depot, bagel store, and a couple of restaurants. It is worth the move!!

Atria Crossroads Place in Waterford, CT
4.2

Our first impression was with the community itself, it is so clean, very bright, open, sunny and airy. Most of the staff members have been great, but we have had a few issues that take much longer than needed to get resolved and some of that has to do with their responsiveness.

HarborChase of Madison

100 Bradley Road, Madison, CT 06443

Starting at$X,XXX+ monthly
Photo of HarborChase of Madison
14
14 Photos available
3
3 Floor plans available
9.6
Review Score
27 reviews

HCM provided my 93 year old mother with a wonderful welcome. Staff and residents have been friendly and warm. Everyone has gone out of their way to love her needs. Thank you.

Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care
See all Harbor Retirement Associates LLC communities

The Hearth is proud to offer Viking Pure Solutions’ electrochemically activated cleaning and disinfecting systems for our residents in each of our communities! This revolutionary safe and effective cleaner provides protection for our residents, teams, and families providing state of the art...

... Read more

Atria Crossroads Place

One Beechwood Drive, Waterford, CT 06385

Starting at$X,XXX+ monthly
14
14 Photos available
14
14 Floor plans available
8.9
Review Score
73 reviews

Tuesday my friend and I went to visit my mother in law at Atria. When we arrived my mother in law was not there. Atria had taken everyone from Memory Care out on a bus ride! How wonderful! They were so...

Provides: Independent Living, Assisted Living, Memory Care
See all Atria communities

Exciting NEW enhancements are now complete at Atria Crossroads Place! Extensive renovations include refurbished common spaces, an upgraded salon, a modern bistro, redesigned restaurant and private dining room with outdoor canopy, library, custom fitness center, additional outdoor green space and...

... Read more

Crescent Point At Niantic

417 Main Street, Niantic, CT 06357

Starting at$X,XXX+ monthly
15
15 Photos available
3
3 Floor plans available
6.8
Review Score
33 reviews

Crescent point is awesome. My mother who is beyond picky, really loves the staff and the place. I cant say how much this place is wonderful! They even allow her old cat which has made a huge difference.

Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care
See all Benchmark Senior Living communities

Exceptional assisted living services in a residential living environment is the cornerstone of Crescent Point at Niantic. Crescent Point captures the spirit of village convenience and accessibility while embracing the neighborhood feel of a front porch and good friends. While the environment is...

... Read more

The Villa at Westhampton

68 Old Country Road, Westhampton, NY 11977

2
2 Photos available
8 reviews

Like many of you, our mother along with many other moms, grandmothers, aunts, uncles and friends are living in Assisted Living facilities all over the country. During this dark time in our history, we can...

Provides: Assisted Living, Memory Care

The Villa at Westhampton is an exclusive assisted living community nestled along 18 lush acres of sprawling lawns, spectacular gardens, walking paths and picturesque views. Moments away from the majestic Hamptons beaches and Westhampton Performing Arts Center, truly a port of call to an exciting...

... Read more

Complete Care at Groton Regency

1145 Poquonnock Rd, Groton, CT 06340

13
13 Photos available
2 reviews

Groton regency retirement is a hidden gem. They are slowly redoing rooms and the general Spaces are pretty classy. The staff is amazing and the entire place is uplifting. Most of they're staff has been...

Provides: Independent Living, Assisted Living, Memory Care
See all Complete Care Management communities

Groton Regency Retirement, a Senior Living Community, is located along side Groton Regency Center, a skilled nursing facility. Active seniors can enjoy a fun, dynamic lifestyle at Groton Regency Retirement. Our lively community supports each resident's independence, while also offering...

... Read more

Peconic Landing At Southold

53345 Main Rd, Southold, NY 11971

Provides: Independent Living, Assisted Living, Nursing Homes

New England Village

Old Forge Road/Route 1, Westbrook, CT 06498

Provides: Senior Apartments

New England Village

Old Forge Road/Route 1, Westbrook, CT 06498

Provides: Senior Apartments

Yankee Village

Harvey Drive/Route 1, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

Provides: Senior Apartments

Yankee Village

Harvey Drive/Route 1, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

Provides: Senior Apartments

Our free advisors can help

    • Compare local facilities
    • Determine care type
    • Schedule tours
    • Evaluate pricing

Woodbridge of Hampton Bays ( and Farmingdale)

10 Springville Road, Hampton Bays, NY 11901

Provides: Independent Living, Senior Apartments

Woodbridge of Hampton Bays ( and Farmingdale)

10 Springville Road, Hampton Bays, NY 11901

Provides: Independent Living, Senior Apartments

The Family Lodge of Clinton

91 East Main Street attn: Independent Living, Clinton, CT 06413

Provides: Independent Living

Ahepa 250 Apartments

267 Roxbury Rd, Niantic, CT 06357

1 review
Provides: Independent Living

Essex Meadows

30 Bokum Rd, Essex, CT 06426

Provides: Independent Living, Assisted Living
See all Life Care Services LLC communities

Meadowbrook Manor

1251 S Main St, Middleton, CT 06457

Provides: Assisted Living

Located just outside the charming rural Connecticut Village of Essex, Meadowbrook Manor is a wonderful residential care home with a relaxed, friendly atmosphere and a professional caring staff. The fully air-conditioned home features private and semi-private rooms, 24 hour care, three home cooked...

... Read more

Riverhead Landing

1145 Middle Rd., Riverhead, NY 11901

5 reviews

My name is Demetria [Removed] I live in apt.[Removed]. I just would like to give Riverhead landing a 5 star rating. They are efficient and courteous. And are very helpful with paperwork. The maintenance...

Provides: Senior Apartments

Homestead Madison

391 Boston Post Rd, Madison, CT 06443

12
12 Photos available
Provides: Independent Living

Maintaining independence is wonderful-but living independently doesn't have to mean living alone and contending with everyday tasks and responsibilities that can become overwhelming.The Homestead provides everything needed to enjoy independent living that is not only comfortable and safe, but...

... Read more

Homestead Madison

391 Boston Post Rd, Madison, CT 06443

12
12 Photos available
Provides: Independent Living

Maintaining independence is wonderful-but living independently doesn't have to mean living alone and contending with everyday tasks and responsibilities that can become overwhelming.The Homestead provides everything needed to enjoy independent living that is not only comfortable and safe, but...

... Read more

AHEPA 250 Apartments

95 Clark Ln, Waterford, CT 06385

Provides: Independent Living

AHEPA 250 Apartments

95 Clark Ln, Waterford, CT 06385

Provides: Independent Living

Pride Point Apartments

21 Laurel Drive, New London, CT 06320

Provides: Senior Apartments

Pride Point Apartments

21 Laurel Drive, New London, CT 06320

Provides: Senior Apartments

Progress Point Apartments

21 Laurel Drive, New London, CT 06320

Provides: Senior Apartments

Progress Point Apartments

21 Laurel Drive, New London, CT 06320

Provides: Senior Apartments
Viewing 1-25 out of 30 communities

Cost of independent living in Shelter Island, NY

The average cost of senior living in Shelter Island is 7,209 per month. Cheaper nearby regions include Westhampton Beach, NY with an average of 4,881 per month.

Monthly average independent living cost comparisons
Care type:
Your actual costs may be higher or lower than the average.
Get advice from a local expert:

Discover the many ways to pay for senior living

Planning ahead can better position you to make good choices for your loved one’s care in the future. But if your aging family member needs care now, there are ways to finance the cost of long-term care through a combination of approaches.

What is independent living?

Independent living offers a stress-free lifestyle for older adults. Independent living communities don’t provide personal care or supervision, but do offer generally healthy adults opportunities for socialization and hassle-free living. Independent living services often include:

  • Nutritious meals and snacks
  • Housekeeping
  • Laundry
  • Home maintenance and repairs
  • Social activities and outings
Complete guide to independent living

Frequently asked questions

Spring Village at Stratford, Colebrook Village at Hebron and The Watermark at 3030 Park, a CCRC are the top-rated independent living facilities near Shelter Island, New York. See full list of communities.

There are 30 independent living facilities near Shelter Island, New York. See the full list.

More questions?

Ask an A Place for Mom local advisor at no cost.

The information contained on this page is for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute medical, legal or financial advice or create a professional relationship between A Place for Mom and the reader. Always seek the advice of your health care provider, attorney or financial advisor with respect to any particular matter, and do not act or refrain from acting on the basis of anything you have read on this site. Links to third-party websites are only for the convenience of the reader; A Place for Mom does not endorse the contents of the third-party sites.